Judging Best Orphan Director Nominees Since 1998

In the years before the ten picture system, there was the occasional divergence between the five Best Picture nominations and the Best Picture nominations at the Academy Awards. Here’s a rundown of these “orphans”.

1998-Peter Weir: The Truman Show-I tend to think of Weir’s strength as delicately structured epics with sweeping visuals. “The Truman Show” was certainly a shift for Weir but he’s a great director, brought great performances in his cast, and this is one of the best films of 1998 period. With snubs for Best Picture, Best Actor, and Best Supporting Actress, I’m glad this film got rewarded somewhere.
Grade: B+

1999-Spike Jonze: Being John Malkovich is more of a Charlie Kaufman film than a Spike Jonze film. This was earlier in Kaufman’s career, so the Academy probably wasn’t aware that Kaufman was the genius who made it happen. It’s also unfortunate that Frank Darabont got snubbed here for a film that’s still highly regarded and when one considers that he also got snubbed for “The Shawshank Redemption.” If they were going to snub “Green Mile”, I would have preferred the Academy have gone with “Talented Mr. Ripley” and Anthony Minghella.
Grade: C-

2000-Stephen Daldry: Billy Elliot- I’m not too opposed to Lasse Holstrom getting snubbed since he got nominated the year prior and “Chocolat” is very much Oscar-bait film of the least deserved BP nom of the decade. But why Daldry? Rob Zemeckis, who’s always quite innovative…